January renewal reviews

An anonymous R2I client story · Logistics

Less spent.
More protection.

Approximate annual plan savings≈$102k
versus the proposed renewalAbout 30% lower

A lower medical budget. A lower deductible. Less out-of-pocket exposure for employees.

Also about $71k below the prior plan’s annualized cost.

Put your renewal to the test

Total medical cost, employer and employee combined. Selected cost reported by R2I; savings are approximate.

Architectural illustration of a logistics truck and distribution center.
The employer75 employees
Medical enrollment50 enrolled
Annual medical cost≈$240k
Copay plan
$1,500
Lower PPO deductible

$5,000 → $3,500 · Individual, in network

HSA-compatible plan
$2,000
Lower out-of-pocket limit

$7,000 → $5,000 · Individual, in network

Employee cost
0%
Increase in employee cost

Unchanged, as reported by R2I

The starting point

The renewal went up.
The plan cost came down.

A logistics business with 75 employees and 50 enrolled employees faced a fully insured renewal of $341,678 a year. Its prior plan’s annualized quoted cost was $311,179.

R2I reviewed a level-funded alternative on a national network. The selected program’s reported annual medical cost was approximately $240,000, with lower deductibles and out-of-pocket exposure in the benefit design.

Inside the review

Three parts of one decision.

The full cost picture

Current cost, the fully insured renewal, and the level-funded alternative were reviewed together, accounting for enrollment.

The benefit details

Two medical options, with attention to deductibles, out-of-pocket limits, office visits, and prescription benefits.

Network access

A national provider network was part of the alternative. Network and benefit differences were considered alongside the price.

The annual cost difference

The savings.
In real dollars.

Approximately $240,000 in annual medical cost, compared with a $341,678 renewal. A meaningful change in the benefits budget.

Annual medical cost50 enrolled employees
  1. Prior-year planAnnualized quoted cost
    $311,179
    Baseline
  2. Proposed renewalFully insured
    $341,678
    +9.8%
  3. Selected planLevel-funded · reported cost
    ≈$240,000
    ≈−23%
Prior-year planProposed renewalSelected plan

Selected annual cost is approximately $240,000, as reported by R2I. Prior-year and renewal amounts are annualized from the 50-enrollee quote. Total medical cost includes employer and employee contributions. Savings are rounded. Percent changes compare with the prior-year plan. Bars start at zero.

The benefit value

A smaller bill.
More protection.

The cost reduction came with specific improvements in what employees could owe for care. Individual, in-network benefits are shown below.

PPO deductibleThe copay plan
$1,500 lower

30% lower deductible

HSA out-of-pocket limitThe health savings account-compatible plan
$2,000 lower

About 29% less maximum exposure

What that can mean for an employee

$1,200 less out of pocket.

In the analysis’s example of $6,000 in covered, in-network care, the member’s cost under the copay plan falls from $5,200 to $4,000.

Prior PPO$5,200
Selected PPO$4,000

Illustrative member cost, not an actual claim or a certified actuarial valuation. Assumes all $6,000 is subject to the individual deductible and 20% member coinsurance. No actuarial-value percentage is claimed.

The health savings account-compatible plan’s deductible remained $5,000. Provider access, some copays, and prescription terms changed; the improvements above do not mean every benefit was identical.

Beyond medical

More opportunities
in the benefits package.

The review also identified proposed savings in dental, vision, and employer-paid life coverage. These are separate opportunities and are not included in the medical savings above.

≈$2,028per year

Proposed employee savings

Lower combined dental and vision premiums for the enrolled group, compared with renewal.

≈$1,257per year

Proposed employer savings

Lower premiums for employer-paid life and accidental death coverage, on the same insured volume.

These proposed changes create savings opportunities for both employees and the business. Estimates reflect quoted enrollment and insured volume and are separate from medical savings.

At a glance

The comparison behind the story.

Anonymous logistics employer · 75 employees · 50 enrolled employees
Plan detailPrior-year planSelected program
Annual total medical cost$311,179 annualized≈$240,000
FundingFully insuredLevel-funded
PPO deductible$5,000$3,500
HSA out-of-pocket limit$7,000$5,000
Employee costExisting employee costUnchanged, per R2I

Client identity withheld; results are shown in aggregate. Selected annual cost is approximately $240,000, as reported by R2I. Prior-year and renewal amounts are annualized from the 50-enrollee quote. Total medical cost includes employer and employee contributions. Savings are rounded. Enrollment mix and plan terms can affect the comparison. Benefit amounts are individual and in network. Results vary by employer, underwriting, and selected plan.

Explore more client results

Your next move

What’s possible
with your renewal?

Start with your current plan and the questions you need answered.

Request a renewal review